Skip to main content
A simple, black outline of a sheep sitting.
Hammondsport, NY
(607) 569-3767
A simple, black outline of a sheep sitting.
  • A charming two-story house with green shutters and a circular design, surrounded by neatly trimmed bushes.

Welcome to Black Sheep Inn

The historic 1859 T.M. Younglove Octagon House

Come and enjoy New York Finger Lakes hospitality and charm with activities for everyone. Black Sheep Inn is nestled on the south end of Keuka Lake in Hammondsport. This Octagon House is unique amongst the surrounding colonial houses, sitting on a knoll with ridges wrapping around it and gardens to walk through and sitting areas to enjoy on the property’s 2 ½ acres. Walking into our bed and breakfast, you are transported back in time with original wood floors, wallpapered rooms, and period furniture throughout the historic octagon home. Large open common areas from the Billiard room to the Cupola Ballroom for our guests' relaxation, social gatherings, and even piano playing.

A couple stands by a "Black Sheep Inn" sign, with a dog and a view of the inn in the background.

Hospitality is the Heart of the Inn

Upon arrival, guests are warmly welcomed by the Innkeepers, Kim, Gary, and their dog, Rex. Having moved in September 2025 from Virginia, they love to share the history of the Younglove Octagon House as well as the activities around Keuka and the other Finger Lakes. The guests' experience, enjoyment, and relaxation is at the forefront of their hospitality. Celebrating the Finger Lakes, Kim sources breakfast locally. Enjoy a 2-course meal that includes a salad 100% grown on the property year-round. Gary shares his experiences in the area and suggestions for activities based on guests' interests. And Rex is the official welcomer, who loves to share his new home with all of the guests.
Our History

Thoughtfully Appointed Suites

Celebrating the rich history of the inn, our six suites are each named to reflect the home’s place in history. All of our rooms have private baths and views of either the back gardens and terrace or the front ridgeline and pleasant valley. The suites take advantage of the octagon house, using unusable space for the closets and bathrooms, leading to oddly shaped areas and maximizing livable space throughout the Inn. T.M. Younglove would be proud of the space utilization.

A cozy bedroom featuring a wooden bed, colorful pillows, a side table with a lamp, and a doorway leading to a bathroom.
Cozy bedroom featuring a four-poster bed with a white quilt, an orange throw, and soft lighting.
Cozy bedroom with a floral-patterned bedspread, a dresser, and large windows.
Book Your Stay
A serene gorge featuring cascading waterfalls and a stone bridge surrounded by lush greenery.

Explore the Finger Lakes

Nestled in the heart of New York’s Finger Lakes region, Black Sheep Inn places guests just moments from the beauty of Keuka Lake and the many experiences that make the area unforgettable. Spend your days exploring scenic lakeside towns, sipping world-class wines, craft beers, and spirits from the region’s celebrated wineries and breweries, or discovering one-of-a-kind treasures created by talented local artisans. Whether you’re seeking outdoor adventure, peaceful waterfront moments, or a leisurely afternoon of shopping and tasting, the Finger Lakes offers the perfect blend of relaxation, culture, and natural beauty.
Area Activities
A sunlit canyon with steep, rocky walls and lush greenery.
A woman in a wide-brimmed hat rows a canoe on a calm lake.
A group of people toasting with glasses of red wine.

Celebrate, Relax & Indulge

A couple sits together on a dock, embracing as the sun sets over the water.

Elevated Getaway Experiences

Treat your loved one to that special experience on or around the lake.
Packages
A bouquet of six red roses in a clear vase.

Enhance Your Stay

Enhance your stay with items individually suited to you and your special someone.
Enhancements
Two silver wedding rings resting on a textured black surface.

Micro Weddings and Special Events

Create the perfect intimate wedding and event that has what you need and want.
Special Events
A large, octagonal house with green shutters and a porch surrounded by trees.

Stay Somewhere Truly One of a Kind

Steeped in history and surrounded by the natural beauty of the Finger Lakes, Black Sheep Inn invites guests to experience the warmth, wonder, and distinctive charm of one of the region’s rare octagon homes. Here, peaceful mornings, meaningful conversations, lakeside adventures, and thoughtful hospitality come together to create the kind of getaway you’ll talk about for years to come.